Mark Cuban and the NFT Community oppose OpenSea's royalty reform
In a surprising twist, prominent figures including billionaire entrepreneur Mark Cuban and NFT creator Yuga Labs, known for the Bored Ape Yacht Club NFTs, have criticized OpenSea, a popular NFT trading platform. The backlash followed OpenSea's recent announcement that it would no longer uphold creator royalties, sparking significant outrage within the community.Mark Cuban, a recognized figure in the tech and NFT domains, expressed his strong disagreement with OpenSea's decision on Twitter. He emphasized the gravity of the situation, highlighting that abandoning the collection and payment of royalties for NFT sales could not only undermine trust in the platform but also have broader negative implications for the entire NFT industry. Cuban's input held weight due to his reputation and experience in the cryptocurrency space, including his previous investment in OpenSea during its Series A funding round in 2021.OpenSea's alteration in its approach to creator royalties, effective from August 31, caused ripples throughout the NFT ecosystem. Previously, creator royalties ranging from 2.5% to 10% played a crucial role in ensuring artists received compensation beyond their initial sale. This change disproportionately impacted artists and teams reliant on passive income from secondary sales.Many speculated that this shift was a response to pressure from other NFT marketplaces that had already reduced or eliminated creator royalties to attract buyers. OpenSea's CEO and co-founder, Devin Finzer, had previously underscored the significance of creator fees in protecting artists' rights.Notably, Cuban's criticism carried a unique weight given his affinity for NFTs and his prior investment in OpenSea. Despite his involvement in the platform's Series A funding round, those who believed creator royalties were pivotal to NFT ecosystem integrity rallied behind his viewpoint.Yuga Labs, the creator of Bored Ape Yacht Club NFTs, joined the chorus of dissent against OpenSea. In response to the policy change, Yuga Labs declared its intention to gradually disassociate from OpenSea. Their response centered on the impact of OpenSea's decision on the NFT creator community.In a related development, a group of investors who purchased Bored Ape Yacht Club NFTs initiated a lawsuit against Sotheby's Holdings Inc. and various celebrities, including Paris Hilton, Gwyneth Paltrow, and Kevin Hart. The lawsuit alleged that misleading advertising and misrepresentations of NFT values had fostered false expectations of profit. The investors claimed they bought the NFTs with profit expectations that were not fulfilled.While Bored Ape NFTs once commanded six-figure values during the peak of the NFT craze, their prices have significantly dropped on platforms like OpenSea. This case underscored the complexities of the NFT market and the potential legal challenges that may arise as the market landscape evolves.In summary, OpenSea's decision to cease enforcing creator royalties has triggered strong disapproval from notable figures like Mark Cuban and influential NFT creators like Yuga Labs. This controversy has shed light on the intricate nature of the NFT ecosystem and has drawn attention to the challenges and potential legal ramifications within the evolving NFT market.
Read more